Extended Essay - How does the work of African social commentary artist, Romuald Hazoumé demonstrate tension between African and European Cultures?


International Baccalaureate
Extended Essay - Visual Arts

Abstract

Within this research investigation I have explored Romuald Hazoumé’s body of work in relation to my research question:

How does the work of African social commentary artist, Romuald Hazoumé demonstrate tension between African and European Cultures?

Hazoumé’s work references many different cultures and their histories. The scope of his body of work is vast. In this research investigation I have limited this scope to best illustrate the aspects of Hazoumé’s work that demonstrate the tension between these cultures. The aspects are: Hazoumé’s reference to traditional African mask making practices; his commentary on slave and oil theft in Africa; and his visual documentation of the lives of the Benin petrol smugglers.

To best illustrate these aspects I have constructed an in-depth analysis of two of Hazoumé’s works, La Bouche Du Roi and his mask series. I have also explored the commentary aspects of his works, Roulette Béninoise and Made in Porto-Novo.

From my analysis of these works and the particular aspects which I focused on, I have concluded that Hazoumé’s work demonstrates tension between African and European cultures on many different levels. Hazoumé uses his material choice to comment on slave and oil theft in Africa. This has caused tension between these two cultures for centuries as Europeans exploit Africa. Hazoumé also uses the imagery of masks to reference the art practice of 20th century avant-garde artists and the theft of traditional art that has occurred in the international art community. Hazoumé also uses visual storytelling techniques to depict the lives of petrol smugglers in Benin and to show European gallery audience how their lifestyle is affecting the African people.

By combining these elements in carefully constructed artworks that have rich cultural significance and beautiful social commentary aspects, Hazoumé’s work is able to demonstrate the tension between African and European cultures.

Word Count: 300

Introduction

Romuald Hazoumé is an African social commentary artist. Born in Benin, his cultural heritage is the keystone of his arts practice. After workshopping with Hazoumé in the Brisbane Gallery of Modern Art (GoMA) on the M.I.B (Made in Brisbane) project I was compelled to look further into how Romuald Hazoumé ‘s work demonstrates tension between African and European Cultures. I wanted to concentrate particularly on his mask series, three pieces of which were purchased by GoMA along with two of his photographs for the 21st Century Art: art in the first decade exhibition (18 December 2010 – 26 April 2011).

The Republic of Benin is a small country in the west of Africa that borders Nigeria. Romuald Hazoumé works and resides in Benin’s capital, Porto-Novo, a lowly populated city just off the coast. Benin’s largest city however is Cotonou. Resting on the small coastal stretch of Benin it is very heavily populated in comparison to Porto-Novo. Hazoumé’s work draws from both the heavy urbanization of Cotonou and the natural environment of Porto-Novo.

As well as using his country’s environment to influence his arts practice, Hazoumé’s material choice is keystone in his presentation of themes and concepts. His use of discarded materials is a highly symbolic reference to the culture and history of Africa, both contemporary and historical. Hazoumé comments particularly on slave trade in Africa. It is because of this symbolism that his work has been so well received by the art world.

Traditional African art has a history of exhibition in European galleries. It is particularly well known for the influence it had on 20th Century European avant-garde art. Hazoumé plays off this history in a whimsical way that develops his strong standing as a commentary artist. Secondary sources such as exhibition catalogues, curator’s comments, didactics and texts concerning the history of African art will be used to further explore this history that Hazoumé comments on.

Although GoMA has exhibited African art in the past, Hazoumé’s marks and photographs were GoMA’s first major purchase of contemporary African art. Their selection of Hazoumé’s work and the context it was exhibited in highlighted the historical significance of the work in a global context. Hazoumé's work has been exhibited all over the world. He first exhibited at Night of Art in Helsinki, Finland in 1990 and is now exhibiting in GoMA. This is due to his ability to reflect on not only his cultures traditional arts practice but also that of European avant-garde artists.

This is why his art practice, and the exploration of it in this essay is so important to the art world.  By analyzing Hazoumé’s mask series along with his other works, La Bouche Du Roi and Roulette Béninoise, in relation to their placement within the context in European art history I will be able to highlight the tension between African and European culture that he brings to demonstrate in his work.

La Bouche Du Roi

 [Fig. 1.]
La Bouche Du Roi
Romuald Hazoumè (Benin)
1997-2005
The British Museum 
The Menil Collection, Houston 


La Bouche Du Roi was one of Hazoumé’s first works to be exhibited in western society. It combines several different themes and concepts, one of the most prominent being the trade of slaves from Africa to the Caribbean and America. La Bouche Du Roi translates to Mouth of the King. The title is referring to a place in the republic of Benin where slaves were gathered together to be traded.

Upon first viewing this work in photographs the thing that comes across the strongest is the immense scale of the work. This would be even more overwhelming when viewing the work in person. The work uses repetition very pointedly to convey symbolic meaning. I did not realize until I researching the work and spoke with Hazoumé. An audience member, who also lacked this context for the work, may find the repetition easy to become lost in, consequently missing the small symbols within the work.

The work consists of many different factors that contribute to its overall meaning. It merges materials such as jerry cans and spices as well as digital video and audio. The items are positioned on the floor to create a representation of the famous print of the 18th century slave ship The Brookes, a copy of which was exhibited next to the work.

[Fig. 2.] “The Brookes" print - inspiration for "La Bouche Du Roi"

The work aims to provoke the feeling that the audience is in the slave ship. This is exhibited through the incorporation of smell, sound, sight, and scale. From discussions with Hazoumé and curators didactics I learned that spices were incorporated into the work for two reasons. Firstly, they were one of the many things traded and stolen from Africa and taken to European countries. Secondly, they were used to provide scents that would give the façade that the audiences were in the slave ship. As well as spices for scent to create this effect, audio was played around the sculpture and at the bow of the ship a video work was shown depicting the smuggling of petrol across the borders of Nigeria and Benin. The mass scale of the work also contributes to this façade Hazoumé creates by dwarfing the audience member in comparison, making them feel insignificant and positioning them in the situation the slaves onboard the ship would have been in.


Within the composition repetition is essential. The repetition of the shape, size and colour of the jerry cans is symbolic of the views Europeans had of Africans. Europeans treated Africans as objects they could steal and trade and to the Europeans they all looked the same. This repetition is also used to more successfully portray the print of The Brooks. The colours in the work use a dull palette. This is to illustrate the bleak nature of slave trade and also create the mood and emotion that would have been present on the ship.

 [Fig. 3.]
Detail of “La Bouche Du Roi”

A focal point is created in the work. Towards the starboard of the ship a penetrating yellow breaks the dull colour scheme. The yellow jerry can is composed to form a mask wearing a crown. Next to it is a black mask. This mask also draws in your attention as it is situated next to the focal point and spacing has been left around it to isolate it from the rest of the jerry cans.

When speaking to Hazoumé about this work he said that these two masks symbolized the two governments involved in the trade of artefacts from Africa. The yellow mask symbolized the European government and the black mask the African government. The black mask is positioned next to the yellow mask to illustrate how the African government was taking a back seat to the government of the European nations and in a metaphorical sense, letting them drive the boat.

Between these two masks are the scales of justice tipping slightly towards the yellow mask. Above the two masks is a rifle. These two elements together are symbolic of the tension between these two societies at the time. Europeans saw the wealth Africa had to offer, in minerals, spices, slaves and now oil. They used force to steal these items from Africa as symbolized by the rifle and the African government allowed them to do it. When asking Hazoumé about this conflict he said to me,

“Everyone thinks of Africa as a poor country but we are not poor, we are very rich and our government does not know how to deal with this wealth so they let others take it.” (Hazoumé, 2010)

La Bouche Du Roi was first exhibited in the British Museum from 22 March to 13 May 2007 as part of the celebration of the bicentenary of the establishment of the Slave Trade Act. The context in which it was exhibited adds to the tension that Hazoumé illustrates in his work. Hazoumé spoke to me about how he creates his works with the intention of them being exhibited in western society. Critics of the bicentennial exhibition at the British Museum raised the point that exhibiting these contemporary works that speak so strongly about the theft of, not only slaves but also cultural artefacts only draws attention to the fact that this is what the British museum did.

The contemporary works purchased by the British museum were exhibited along side the permanent collection that consists of some African historical artefacts that were taken from the continent around the same time as the slave trade that La Bouche De Roi addresses. Most of the artefacts exhibited from Africa in the British Museum are African masks. Hazoumé comments on this in his use of the jerry cans to represent the faces of the slaves as well as the African styled masks at the starboard of the ship. Hazoumé broadens the significance of this symbol within this work further in his mask series.

Hazoumé uses plastic jerry cans in all of his works. Many of his photographic works and the video element of La Bouche Du Roi depict these cans being used to smuggle items such as rice, water and petrol within Benin and neighboring Nigeria. The jerry cans and the items they carry have a symbolic significance in Hazoumé’s work. Hazoumé uses the jerry cans in his works to comment on the poor quality of life in Africa due to other countries exploiting the continent for its oil. This work also comments on how Africa has always been viewed as a fountain of wealth, in both natural and human recourses, a fountain that Europeans have exploited throughout history.

La Bouche Du Roi uses all of these elements to visually tell the history of slave trade in Africa. The work is rich in symbolism as well as cultural heritage. Hazoumé pushes the work further with the use of recycled and found objects situating the sculpture in a contemporary framework. By combining the use of visual story telling, cultural heritage and contemporary techniques he is able to demonstrate the tension that existed between African and European cultures during this time of conflict.

The Mask Series

[Figs. 4-6.]

Hazoumé extends the concepts he was dealing with in La Bouche Du Roi with his series of masks. Constructed from the same materials as La Bouche Du Roi, plastic jerry cans used to smuggle petrol from Benin to Nigeria, Hazoumé shows the progression of what is being stolen from Africa in this series. Hazoumé uses masks to depict the people who smuggle this petrol, while also connecting back to traditions of African Art and the avant-garde traditions of 20th century European artists.

Hazoumé uses the plastic jerry cans as the base for his works. He also uses other material to add to the aesthetics of his masks. In Liberté, porcupine quills and fabric are used. In other masks Hazoumé uses found objects from the rubbish dumped in Africa by western societies. Hazoumé also uses blown out jerry cans in his masks. His work On/Off is an example of this. The petrol smugglers make these cans by pouring small amounts of petrol into a jerry can then dropping a match into it, thus blowing it out. This is done so that petrol smugglers can hold more petrol in the one can. This however compromises the integrity of the container and makes the transportation process risky.

The colours, tones and composition of each of the masks vary greatly. Hazoumé said that he makes his masks in the images of the people he meets as he follows petrol smugglers around Benin. The unique attributes of these design principles are what give each of these characters their personality. As well as commenting on the smuggling of petrol, Hazoumé makes a comment on human interactions. He spoke to me about how quick we are to judge other people based on how they look. This concept in his work also alludes to the fact that western countries quickly judge Africa as a poor continent based on its appearance.

"Western people have a lot of cliche about Africa, and I'm sad for that. Everyone wants to see old masks from Africa, because that fits the cliche, but what I give them is the new mask from Africa, made with the rubbish they send to us every day, rubbish we didn't need." (Hazoumé, 2010)

By making Masks the subject of his series, Hazoumé creates an interesting feedback loop. African masks have been one of the many artefacts taken from Africa to be exhibited in western galleries. Western culture has a significant domination over the international art community. Being mainly More Economically Developed Countries that have the luxury of being able to invest in art. This has major implications on the culture of Less Economically Developed Countries such as Africa whose traditional artworks are taken away to be exhibited in rich countries. In terms of Hazoumé's work, he makes pieces for the specific purpose of being exhibited in western galleries. This western dominance is what underpins his conceptual approach as he plays off the views Europeans hold of traditional African art.

Frank Willett's book African Art written in 1971 talks about how African art was viewed in a Western culture from several points of view. African art was originally declared 'Primitive Art'. This term was coined in Da Vinci's time. Da Vinci considered painting to be the most evolved form of art. Sculpture, Africa's main art form, was considered the most primitive.

Traditional African sculpture focused on the expression and emotion of each character that was sculptured. Consisting of mainly human forms the works would tell the story of the person much like Hszoumé’s work. This concept of expressionism in art was quite contrary to Da Vinci’s approach, where art was treated as a science or mathematics and art had a correct answer.

However these ideals of what art is, were altered rapidly by the avant-garde artist of the 20th century. Artists such as Man Ray and Picasso were heavily influenced by the expressionistic qualities they discovered, by looking at traditional African art.

[Figs. 7-9.]

Picasso drew connections between African masks and the human form, as can be seen in his work, Head of a Woman. Man Ray took a similar approach in his work Noire at Blanche. The work of these artists during this time was well received by the general public. An increasing popularity of the avant-garde artists meant an increase in demand for traditional African art and even more cultural artefacts were stolen and exhibited in western galleries.

The appreciation of expressionism established in the 20th century has become embodied in 21st century art. Hazoumé plays off this history of avant-garde art, particularly in this series with his imagery of the mask. By creating his work with the intension of their exhibition in western galleries, he is commenting on the fascination that Europeans had of African art a century ago. African masks were taken from their home country to be exhibited in western galleries. Hazoumé explained it to me as an exchange. In exchange for taking their people to be slaves, their oil to run our society and their cultural artefacts for our own fascination, western societies gave Africa their rubbish. Hazoumé makes this rubbish into masks so that he can send it back to the countries that left it there.

“Today, if you want to see the old masks from Africa, you need to go to the British Museum or shops in Paris and London. So I make new ones with the rubbish people send to us from Europe, and I send them back to galleries with my culture inside them. We in Africa are losing our culture and if we lose it, we’re dead. We think your culture is better than ours, but our culture is so rich.” (Hazoumé, 2009)

His contemporary approach to African art continues to influence the western culture just like that of Africa’s traditional artists. The conceptual depth and cultural references of his award winning La Bouche Du Roi are what audiences remember.  Hazoumé’s current series of work focuses on these traditional African art tools of expressionism and storytelling as they take the form of masks created from recycled material. However exhibiting in western galleries is the reason many people describe this series as his ‘tongue in cheek’ masks. By playing off the fascination western societies have with African art and the avant-garde masks, Hazoumé is silently mocking them.

As well as using the imagery of the masks to create this underlying feedback loop Hazoumé uses his choice of media to add another layer of meaning to this series. Although the colour tones and composition varies from work to work, the series is united in its use of media, which is the keystone of Hazoumé’s art practice. There has been a shift in what Western societies are stealing from Africa. After the industrial revolution spanning from the 18th to the 19th century there was a shift in what Western countries needed to run their societies. We moved from needing cheap labor to needing cheap oil. And as rich as Africa was in slaves, Europeans saw that same wealth in their abundance of oil.

La Bouche Du Roi alluded to this shift, as it too, used jerry cans as its main medium. However, that work’s main concept was the trade of slaves, as established by the context it was exhibited in and the imagery of the slave ship. Hazoumé’s mask series focuses on the people that traded this petrol by creating the masks in their image.

His work Liberté, that was purchase by GoMA, also shows the African peoples struggle for freedom from their government and the exploitation by European societies. By referencing the Statue of Liberty, which was a gift from the French to America that symbolized freedom from political uncertainty. Hazoumé makes his reference to European history very clear. Petrol smuggling is very dangerous but many Benin citizens have resorted to it as a means of supporting their families. In Liberté Hazoumé shows these people and their way of life, their struggle for freedom and their frustration with their government. Hazoumé continues their story in many of his photographs as well as in other sculptural works like Roulette Béninoise.

Roulette Béninoise and Made in Porto-Novo

[Fig. 10.]

Romuald Hazoumé
Roulette béninoise (2005)
Installation 
Found materials and photograph

Roulette Béninoise is a sculptural work depicting the means of transport the Benin people use to smuggle petrol across the border. Roulette Benionoise translates to Benin Roulette, referring to the gambling game involving a revolver where the stakes are win it all or die. The term roulette has been engrained into pop culture by its adaptation as a modern gambling game involving a spinning table and a ball. Much like Liberté, Hazoumé references pop culture to highlight his works’ connection to European history and society. By naming his work this, Hazoumé is referring to the stakes that the petrol smugglers expose themselves to.

The work is constructed from found objects. A motorized bicycle loaded with jerry cans is situated in front of a photograph of Benin. The Bike is typical of that used by the petrol smugglers. It’s very unstable and is made more so when carrying such large loads. Hazoumé spoke about the unstable nature and risk of riding these bikes, in an interview with GoMA. This aspect of balance in the composition could also be symbolic of the state of the African government. They are struggling with how to balance their wealth and standing in a global sense. Getting this balance right would benefit Africa significantly, but getting it wrong, which it would appear is doing now, is killing the continent.

The composition of the photograph shows a small dirt road made from bicycle tracks. The tracks are leading to a lush forest with a large tree situated in the center of the photograph. This could be symbolic of the journey the petrol smugglers make in their attempt to gain a better life, but to get there they have to travel across an uncertain path. The name is part of this symbolism. By Roulette, Hazoumé is referring to the fact that the petrol smugglers work with the ultimate stakes, where they could gain a lot of money or lose their life.

Hazoumé often mixes elements of sculpture, video, audio and photography in his works, as he did with La Bouche Du Roi. Another one of his works that used audio, as a key factor was his sculptural work Made in Porto-Novo.

[Fig. 11]
Romuald Hazoumé
Made in Porto-Novo 2009
Found Objects Installation (with audio).


Constructed from several black jerry cans the work forms four musical instruments. The inside of the sculpture has been rigged with speakers to play a track, composed by Hazoumé, that is a mix of sounds he recorded, while following the petrol smugglers around Benin. The track consists of sounds such as: the gulping of petrol being poured into a jerry can; the sound of a motorbike starting up; and eggs frying as the young smugglers made their breakfast.


The goal of Made in Porto-Novo is very similar to that of Hazoumé’s photographic works, where sets out to document the lives of the petrol smugglers. Roulette Beninoise and Hazoumé’s photographs open a door to the Western world, so that they may see the implications that their way of life and their societies dependence on cheap oil has on other cultures around the world. Often we are ignorant to how we impact the lives of other people and Hazoumé is able to give these people a voice.

The themes that run through Hazoumé’s body of work add different readings to each individual piece. In La Bouche Du Roi black jerry cans were used to symbolize African people. In his mask series the spouts of the cans were made to look like mouths. In Made in Porto-Novo, the spouts of the jerry cans are the means of letting the sound inside escape. Hazoumé, through his works, is giving the African people a voice to be heard around the world.

In Hazoumé’s latest works he is able to show more of the story of these petrol smugglers. By illustrating the impact that Westerners dependence on oil has had on his home country, he is able to show a different tension that is present between the two societies. As westerners blindly exploit Africa for its oil, we force a life of poverty and insecurity upon the African people.

Conclusion

Romuald Hazoumé’s work has demonstrated tension between African and European cultures on numerous levels. In La Bouche Du Roi he addressed the trade of Slaves from Africa to The Caribbean and America. He also alluded to the shift in what was traded in using jerry cans as his medium.

Hazoumé explores this shift in trade further with his masks series. He visually documents the people that trade oil and highlights the snap judgments Europeans make of others and Africa as a continent. In this series Hazoumé also addresses Western societies views of African art and emphasizes the importance of the mask as an African cultural artefact. He also references the avant-garde symbolism of African masks.

In his latest photographic and mixed media works like Roulette Beninoise and Made in Porto-Novo Hazoumé presents western galleries with a documentation of European exploitation of the African culture to run their societies.

From the progression of his early mask works and La Bouche Du Roi to his new works, Hazoumé also shows a progression in his story telling. His new works imply that there is now knowledge of the exploitation of Africa in western societies and the African people have been given a chance to let their voice be heard. By looking at Hazoumé’s body of work from start to finish in this essay and exploring it in relation to the theme of tension between African and European cultures we are able to see how his work, and contemporary African art is challenging audiences and will continue to do so, to allow the voices of the African people to be heard.

From the progression in Hazoumé’s work he creates a commentary on the evolution of European society’s relationship with Africa. From the 16th century slave trade to the 21st century exploitation of oil, Romuald Hazoumé shows us that this relationship has always been one of exploitation filled with tension.

Word Count: 3999 words

Bibliography

Texts

Bouttiaux, AM. (2009). Persona. Masks of Africa: Identities Hidden and Revealed. Milan, Italy: 5 Continents Edition.

Buchholz, E. L. Zimmermann, B. (2005). Pablo Picasso. Life and work. Germany: KÖNEMANN

Caacart. “Romuald Hazoumé” Accessed February 17, 2011. http://www.caacart.com/html/Romuald-Hazoume-african-art.html

Enwezor, O. (2006). Snap judgments : new positions in contemporary African photography. Göttingen: Steidl.

Gavin, F. (2007, 22 March). Art for fair trade coffee drinkers? [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.guardian.co.uk/artanddesign/artblog/2007/mar/22/artforthefairtradecoffee

Livewell, D. (2009, February 18). Basic Instinct [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://artblogbybob.blogspot.com/2009/02/basic-instinct.html

Mack, J. (1994). Masks and the art of expression. New York: H.N. Abrams

Njami, S. (2005). Africa Remix: Contemporary Art of a Continent. London: Hatje Cantz.

Queensland Art Gallery Resources (2010). Romuald Hazoumè. Retrieved from http://qag.qld.gov.au/exhibitions/past/2010/21st_Century/artists/romuald_hazoume

Robertson, J. (2010). African artist Romuald Hazoume at centre of upcoming GoMA exhibition. The Courier-Mail. Retrieved from: http://www.news.com.au/

Sannes, G. W. (1970) African ‘primitives’: function and form in African masks and figures. New York: Africana Pub. Corp.

Sorensen, R. (2009). Journey to the spiritual centre. The Australian. Retrieved from: http://www.theaustralian.com.au/

Steward, S. (2009). Romuald Hazoumé's Petrol-Fumed Art. The Arts Desk. Retrieved from: http://www.theartsdesk.com

Trustees of the British Museum (2005). Building the Collection - La Bouche du Roi. Retrieved from http://www.britishmuseum.org/the_museum/museum_in_london/behind_the_scenes/building_the_collection/collecting_la_bouche_du_roi.aspx

Willett, F. (1971). African art: an introduction. London: Thames & Hudson.

Willett, F. (2002). African art: New edition. London: Thames & Hudson.

Video

Armstrong, F. (Writer), Armstrong, F. (Director), & Armstrong, P. (Producer). (2009). The Age of Stupid. [DVD]. United Kingdom: Spanner Films

bbcafrica. (2009, October 22). CSIRO – Romuald Hazoumé [Video file]. Retrieved from http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0L4gejIY2dk

Wickes, B. Kavenagh, M. (2010). 21st Century Artist Interview: Romuald Hazoumé [Vedio podcast]. Retrieved from http://21cblog.com/21c-artist-interview-romuald-hazoume/

Images

[Fig. 11.]         Art Knowledge News Resources. (2009).  A Fascinating Collection of Modern & Contemporary Art ~ The Irish Museum of Modern Art in Dublin. [Image]. Retrieved July 13, 2011, from http://www.artknowledgenews.com/a_fascinating_collection_of_modern_and_contemporary_art_the_irish_museum_of_modern_art_in_dublin.html

[Fig. 7.]            Art Lessons Resources. (2011). The Influence of African Art on
[Fig. 8.]            Cubism. [Image]. Retrieved July 13, 2011, from http://www.artyfactory.com/art_appreciation/art_movements/cubism.htm

[Fig. 1.]            The British Museum. “La Bouche du Roi: an artwork by Romuald Hazoumé” Accessed February 17, 2011. http://www.britishmuseum.org/the_museum/museum_in_the_uk/touring_exhibitions_and_loans/la_bouche_du_roi.aspx

[Fig. 10.]         Caacart. “The Jean Pigozzi Collection” Accessed February 17, 2011. http://www.caacart.com/pigozzi-artist.php?i=Hazoume-Romuald&m=35

[Fig. 4.]            Caacart. “The Jean Pigozzi Collection” Accessed February 17, 2011. http://www.caacart.com/pigozzi-artist.php?i=Hazoume-Romuald&m=35&s=215

[Fig. 9.]            Jacobson, L. (2010). Now on View: “Man Ray: African Art and the Modernist Lens” at the Phillips Collection. [Image]. Retrieved July 13, 2011, from http://www.washingtoncitypaper.com/blogs/artsdesk/general/2010/01/05/now-on-view-man-ray-african-art-and-the-modernist-lens-at-the-phillips-collection/

[Fig. 6.]            May, John. 2009. "New Media: The Wire/The Arts Desk" The Generalist. December 13. Accessed Febuary17, 2011. http://hqinfo.blogspot.com/2009/12/new-media-wirethe-arts-review.html

[Fig. 3.]            Nicholson, Ian. (2007). In memory ... La Bouche du Roi by Romuald Hazoumé at the British Museum. [Image]. Retrieved April 30, 2011, from http://www.guardian.co.uk/artanddesign/artblog/2007/mar/22/artforthefairtradecoffee

[Fig. 5.]            Robertson, Josh. 2010. " African artist Romuald Hazoume at centre of upcoming GoMA exhibition” The Courier-Mail. Accessed February 17, 2011. http://www.news.com.au/african-artist-romuald-hazoume-at-centre-of-upcoming-goma-exhibition/story-e6freqkf-1225935685628

[Fig. 2.]            Wikipedia. “File:Slaveshipposter.jpg” Accessed February 17, 2011. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Slaveshipposter.jpg